I am excited to be starting a PD course on “Making Thinking Visible”, (http://www.visiblethinkingpz.org/VisibleThinking_html_files/03_ThinkingRoutines/03b_Introduction.html) based around a fascinating book with the same title from R.Ritchhart, M.Church and K.Morrison. Ironically I found the book in the Elementary library where they told me it was about to be given away as nobody ever borrowed it.
One of the “thinking routines” I came across in the book is called the 4C’s: Connections, Challenge, Concepts and Changes.
“This routine provides learners with a structure for a text-based discussion built around making connections, asking questions, identifying key ideas, and considering application.” (R.Ritchhart, M.Church and K.Morrison, Making Thinking Visible, p140)
The 4C’s fit in well with G10 English who are completing Othello and preparing to write an essay as a final summative on this part of the TRAGEDY unit. The 4C’s routine appealed to me because it asks the students 4 questions. One of the keys to teaching and learning is asking the right question using the right words and listening to the answer. This activity does precisely that. To get a better idea, here are the questions:
The 4C’s routine (R.Ritchhart, M.Church and K.Morrison, Making Thinking Visible, p140):
- Connections: What connections do you draw between the text (Othello) and your own life or your other learning?
- Challenge: What ideas, positions, or assumptions do you want to challenge or argue with in the text (Othello)?
- Concepts: What key concepts or ideas do you think are important and worth holding on to from the text (Othello)?
- Changes: What changes in attitudes, thinking, or action are suggested by the text (Othello), either for you or others?
While preparing the activity I was a little concerned with the students responses being “shallow”, a point also mentioned in the book. I was also imagining some small group work to be involved but wasn’t quite sure where to do this during the activity and did not need to do it during the first two questions. The activity flowed well, students were given about 5 minutes to write their answers down. Next students reported to the class and discussions arose, points were made, other questions raised and some real critical thinking was being done. Despite only getting through half of the activity in one class the results were great and the objective was met; getting the students to reflect meaningfully before planning, drafting and writing their final essay.
I specifically asked students to give meaning to their answers, explain and justify their ideas which most of them did. Both questions (1 & 2) allowed for some brilliant conversations and ideas to be shared in the class. Students shared some personal experiences and views on racism, sexism which could have been elaborated more if time permitted. The “challenge” question really showed students understanding of the novel and what had frustrated them, Emilia’s death being a popular theme or Iago finally being caught out, stabbed and imprisoned. It was interesting to see how students enjoyed challenging the play too, most students had a clear grudge against something or someone in the play, even Shakespeare himself!
The images of student notes show some variety in language and thought levels besides giving me some indication of their deeper understanding of the play.
Particularly for EAL students, Othello is quite challenging, so it was important for them to have the play broken down, discussed and analyzed. It was good to see that most students had got something out of the play. Curiously I had expected to have to ask “And what makes you say that?” a couple of times to get students to justify their ideas but it wasn’t needed, another indication that students generally got the deeper themes and ideas in the play.
Related and inspirational blogs: